The NASCAR Cup Series is no stranger to high-stakes business battles, but few have captured as much attention—or generated as much controversy—as the ongoing legal and public feud between Rick Ware Racing (RWR) and Legacy Motor Club (LMC), the team co-owned by seven-time champion Jimmie Johnson. At the heart of the dispute is a $45 million charter sale agreement, the most expensive in NASCAR history, and a war of words that has spilled from the courtroom to the court of public opinion. Adding to the intrigue is the recent announcement that T.J. Puchyr, a seasoned NASCAR owner and former Spire Motorsports principal, has agreed to purchase Rick Ware Racing, with plans to expand the team and keep Rick Ware and his son Cody involved.
The Charter Dispute: What Happened?
The conflict began earlier this year when Legacy Motor Club filed a lawsuit against Rick Ware Racing, alleging that RWR had agreed—in writing—to sell one of its charters to the Jimmie Johnson-led group, only to try to back out of the deal. Charters in NASCAR are highly valuable assets, granting teams guaranteed entry into every Cup Series race and a share of the sport’s television revenue. With only 36 charters available, each is worth tens of millions of dollars, and competition to acquire them is fierce.
Legacy Motor Club, which already fields two cars for Erik Jones and John Hunter Nemechek, sought to expand to three full-time entries by purchasing a charter from RWR. According to court documents, the two teams signed a Charter Purchase Agreement in early March, with LMC paying a $750,000 non-refundable deposit. However, shortly after the agreement was executed, confusion arose over which charter was being sold and when the transfer would take place.
RWR currently owns two charters: No. 27, which is leased to RFK Racing for the No. 60 car, and No. 36, used by Cody Ware in the No. 51 entry. RWR claims that the deal was always intended to be for Charter No. 36, not No. 27, and that the contract contained errors and misstatements of fact.
“Should RWR be forced to sell Charter No. 27 for 2026, it would have no charter under which to race and would go out of business. For this reason, RWR would never have agreed (and unequivocally did not agree) to sell Charter No. 27 in advance of the 2026 season.” – RWR stated in court filings.
Legacy Motor Club, on the other hand, insists that the contract clearly refers to Charter No. 27, which is the one currently leased to RFK Racing. During a court hearing, LMC’s attorney argued that the mislabeling was due to misinformation provided by Rick Ware to the attorney drafting the agreement. “It is abundantly clear that this purchase agreement pertains to Charter 27, not 36, despite the mislabeling,” LMC’s lawyer contended. RWR’s attorney countered that Ware always intended to sell Charter 36 and that selling Charter 27 would effectively put the team out of business, as it would leave them without a charter for the 2026 season due to the lease with RFK Racing.
The Legal Battle and Public Fallout
The dispute has escalated into a full-blown legal battle, with RWR filing a countersuit against Legacy Motor Club, seeking to have the agreement declared invalid and to recover legal fees. RWR also claims it attempted to return the $750,000 deposit to LMC, but the money was refused. The stakes are high: if RWR is forced to sell the wrong charter, it could mean the end of the team as a Cup Series competitor.
The public nature of the dispute has added another layer of tension. T.J. Puchyr, who is in the process of acquiring Rick Ware Racing, has spoken out about the situation, defending Rick Ware and criticizing the way Legacy Motor Club has handled the matter.
“If anybody deserves a pass it is Jimmie. But I don’t think he has all the facts, and they tried to humiliate Rick publicly. We don’t do business that way.” – T.J. Puchyr
This sentiment echoes RWR’s official response to the lawsuit, in which the team called the legal action “a misguided attempt to tarnish our reputation” and emphasized its commitment to “the highest standards of integrity and professionalism”.
Legacy Motor Club, for its part, has not shied away from criticizing RWR in court filings, at one point describing the team as “strapped for cash” and “unable to compete at a Cup Series level by its own admission”. The language in the lawsuit is pointed, with LMC asserting that “at the exact same time that Legacy has charted a path forward, RWR has flagged and flailed in the rear”.
The Future: T.J. Puchyr Takes the Helm
Amid the legal turmoil, Rick Ware Racing is undergoing a significant transition. T.J. Puchyr, a former owner at Spire Motorsports, has entered into an agreement to purchase the team, with plans to keep Rick Ware as a partner and retain all current employees, including Cody Ware as a driver. Puchyr is known for his success in building Spire Motorsports into a competitive organization, and he is optimistic about the future of RWR.
“I’ve won at everything I’ve done at every level, and I think we can compete with these guys,” Puchyr told the Associated Press.
“I think we can build it brick-by-brick and it’s going to take people, money and time. It’s not lost on me that [RWR] is the 36th-place car in the garage, we all see it. But I believe we can make this a competitive organization, even a winner” – T.J. Puchyr
Puchyr sees significant value in NASCAR charters, believing they are currently undervalued and could be worth $75 million or more in the future. He plans to expand RWR into a three-car team by 2027, a move that would require acquiring additional charters or leveraging the current legal situation to his advantage.
News in Brief: NASCAR Owner Defends RWR in 45 Million Dollars Feud
The charter dispute between Rick Ware Racing and Legacy Motor Club is more than just a legal squabble—it is a microcosm of the high-stakes, high-pressure world of NASCAR team ownership. The outcome will have implications not only for the two teams involved but also for the broader landscape of the Cup Series, where charters are the lifeblood of competitive teams.
As the legal battle continues, the arrival of T.J. Puchyr as the new owner of Rick Ware Racing signals a new chapter for the team. Whether Puchyr can turn RWR into a competitive force remains to be seen, but his track record and ambition suggest that the team’s future could be brighter than its recent past. For now, all eyes are on the courtroom and the garage, where the fate of NASCAR’s most expensive charter deal—and the reputations of those involved—hang in the balance.
ALSO READ: Rick Ware Racing Faces a Crucial Decision for 2025: Who Will Claim the #51 Ride?
