Denny Hamlin’s criticism of Earnhardts sparks heated debate among NASCAR fans, stirring strong reactions. He questioned if Dale Earnhardt Sr. and Dale Earnhardt Jr. could succeed in today’s racing world. Some fans defended the Earnhardts, while others agreed with Hamlin, saying modern tactics have changed everything. Then, Dale Jr. fired back, calling out Denny Hamlin’s style in another race. Was Hamlin right, or did he go too far?
Key Highlights
- Denny Hamlin questioned the Earnhardts’ ability to excel in modern NASCAR racing on his podcast, ‘Actions Detrimental.
- Hamlin’s remarks sparked significant backlash and debate among NASCAR fans on social media.
- Some fans criticized Hamlin’s understanding of racing dynamics, while others supported his perspective on evolving tactics.
- Dale Earnhardt Jr. responded to Hamlin by critiquing his passive racing style at the Bowman Gray Clash.
- The debate highlights tensions between NASCAR’s past legends and current racing dynamics.
The Iconic 2000 Talladega Victory and Hamlin’s Controversial Statement
In the world of NASCAR, few moments are as unforgettable as Dale Earnhardt Sr.’s jaw-dropping victory at Talladega in 2000.
Picture it: the Intimidator, sitting in 20th place, seemingly out of the race. Yet, in a breathtaking display of skill, he surged through the field, moving from 18th to leading in the final four laps.
This race wasn’t just a win; it was a reflection of Earnhardt’s mastery on superspeedways, forever etching his name in NASCAR history. Enter Denny Hamlin, whose recent comments placed him at the center of controversy.
Hamlin, a skilled racer in his own right, questioned the Earnhardts’ dominance, sparking outrage among fans. The backlash was swift, with fans taking to social media to defend their hero’s legacy.
Although Hamlin sought to soften his statement, the debate highlighted Earnhardt Sr.’s enduring impact and the passion he still inspires.

Denny Hamlin’s Bold Claim about Dale Earnhardt Jr. and Sr.
While the Earnhardt name is practically synonymous with NASCAR greatness, Denny Hamlin’s recent bold claim set off a firestorm among fans.
Hamlin suggested that Dale Earnhardt Sr. and Jr. might struggle with today’s superspeedway racing style. This assertion was made on his podcast, ‘Actions Detrimental,’ where Hamlin remarked, “Dale Jr. and Dale Earnhardt would have never survived in today’s superspeedway racing.” Such a statement was bound to ignite controversy.
Would Dale Earnhardt be able to win with today’s superspeedway package? 🤔@dennyhamlin pic.twitter.com/Up5zOcGbaD
— Dirty Mo Media (@DirtyMoMedia) February 11, 2025
Dale Sr. was legendary, boasting 13 superspeedway wins, while Dale Jr. secured 10 victories on these high-speed tracks.
However, Hamlin pointed out the pronounced difference in racing styles. Today’s races often involve tactical fuel-saving in early stages, with a different drafting approach, contrasting the aggressive, fast-paced tactics the Earnhardts excelled at.
“I’m basically saying they would HATE today’s style of drafting and would not be as successful as they were.” – Denny hamlin
Hamlin clarified that they would dislike and potentially be less successful in the current style, a claim that has stirred considerable debate among NASCAR enthusiasts.
NASCAR Fans’ Reactions and Clarifications from Denny Hamlin
Fans were buzzing with mixed emotions over Denny Hamlin’s comments about the Earnhardts, and the reactions came in thick and fast.
The racing community was divided, with some fans quick to criticize Hamlin’s perspective. One particularly vocal critic questioned Hamlin’s understanding, suggesting he had forgotten Dale Jr.’s tactical alliances on the track, particularly with Tony Stewart, who wasn’t a fellow Chevy driver.
This fan’s attempt to discredit Hamlin, however, didn’t go unchallenged.
“Jesus Hamlin is either ridiculously stupid or has severe memory loss. Jr’s best drafting partner was Stewart who raced for JGR. Jr didn’t care who he raced with if it meant getting to the front…” – NASCAR fans’ reaction
Another fan stepped in with a counterargument, pointing out that Hamlin’s real intention was to emphasize the current state of racing dynamics, where the drafting style once favored by Dale Jr. is now a relic of the past.
“That is his point.. he is saying that the way Jr. drafted doesn’t exist anymore.” – NASCAR fans’ reaction
This clarification seemed to resonate with Hamlin, who expressed his agreement with a sigh of relief, indicating that his point had ultimately been understood.
It highlighted the complexity of modern racing alliances and the evolution of NASCAR tactics.

Dale Jr.’s Criticism of Denny Hamlin’s Racing Style
Denny Hamlin’s comments about the Earnhardts might have stirred the pot among fans, but Dale Earnhardt Jr. had his own thoughts on Hamlin’s racing style.
At the Bowman Gray Clash, Earnhardt Jr. found Hamlin’s approach lacking the intensity fans crave. While the event was chaotic, with Elliott and Hamlin initially dominating, Earnhardt Jr. expected more aggression from Hamlin.
On his ‘Dale Jr Download’ podcast, he expressed surprise that Hamlin didn’t fight harder to reclaim the lead from Elliott. “Chase kind of leaned on [Hamlin] a little bit, and then Denny just fell in behind him,” Earnhardt Jr. remarked, emphasizing fans’ disappointment.
He noted that spectators anticipated more than just clean racing, hinting at a missed opportunity for thrilling on-track battles. Both drivers aired their perspectives publicly, sparking fan discussions.
“Next corner, never f—— touched him. I’m like ‘What are we doing?’ That’s not what anybody that bought a [expletive] ticket to the place wanted. That to me is nothing we can really do about. We can’t really fix that.” – Dale Jr.
Hamlin, known for his calculated racing, faced criticism from Earnhardt Jr., showcasing the contrasting styles between the two racing veterans.

News in Brief: Denny Hamlin’s Criticism of Earnhardts Sparks Heated Debate
As the dust settles on Denny Hamlin’s bold comments about the Earnhardts, NASCAR fans are left buzzing with a mix of admiration and frustration. While some side with Hamlin’s viewpoint, others staunchly defend Dale Jr. and Sr.’s legacy.
The debate has ignited passionate discussions, showcasing the deep-rooted emotions and loyalty within the racing community. Hamlin’s criticism may have sparked controversy, but it undeniably highlights the enduring impact of the Earnhardts on the sport’s history.
ALSO READ: Denny Hamlin Questions NASCAR’s Title Formula and Argues for a More Consistent Champion

