Dale Earnhardt Jr. on NASCAR’s tire gamble raises big questions about Goodyear and its latest option tire. Some drivers saw an edge, while others struggled to adjust. During the 2025 Phoenix Race, Joey Logano used the tire to make up lost ground, but concerns about durability and fairness remain. Dale Earnhardt Jr. shared his thoughts on how this change is shaping competition. His take on whether Goodyear made the right call could shift the debate even further.
Key Highlights
- Dale Earnhardt Jr. criticized the primary tire for grip loss and limiting side-by-side racing.
- He praised the option tire for providing improved speed and competitive racing dynamics.
- Earnhardt Jr. highlighted Joey Logano’s strategic advantage using the option tire at Phoenix.
- The option tire’s impact on race excitement and competitiveness was emphasized by Earnhardt Jr.
- He suggested further improvements to enhance race competitiveness with option tires.
Comparing NASCAR’s Option Tire to F1’s Soft Tires
How do NASCAR’s option tires compare to Formula 1’s soft tires? Both types of tires are engineered to provide improved grip, yet they differ in their application and tactical importance within their respective disciplines.
In Formula 1, soft tires are known for their ability to offer maximum speed, which comes at the cost of rapid wear. This necessitates meticulous race strategy, as selecting the wrong tire compound can dramatically influence race outcomes and potentially decide podium placements.
Similarly, NASCAR’s option tire, developed by Goodyear, mirrors this dynamic by offering better grip with a trade-off in durability. The introduction of the option tire has sparked discussion among drivers and teams, as it adds an extra layer of tactical complexity to race day decisions.
Dale Earnhardt Jr.’s recent commentary on the option tire highlights its impact, suggesting that, much like in Formula 1, tire choice can greatly alter the competitive landscape in NASCAR.
The 2025 Phoenix Race and the Option Tire’s Role
As discussions about tire plans continue from Formula 1 to NASCAR, the 2025 Phoenix Race highlighted the growing significance of Goodyear’s option tire. This race shone a light on the option tire’s unique characteristics and its impact on race dynamics.
Joey Logano’s adept use of the tire allowed him to maintain an impressive speed advantage over competitors who remained on the primary tires, such as Christopher Bell, who struggled to keep pace.
The Isley Brothers said it best: “A little bit softer now (shout!), a little bit softer now.” 🛞
The @DaleJr Download is coming at you now! 🎙️
Apple: https://t.co/e3BrUNSkGu
Spotify: https://t.co/5sGg1NmUbg
YouTube: https://t.co/0aBHYwsxTp pic.twitter.com/2xBjr2CjAk— Dirty Mo Media (@DirtyMoMedia) March 11, 2025
“To me, the option tire doesn’t fall off enough still. It was way too fast for too long.” – TJ
TJ, a respected NASCAR commentator, critiqued the option tire, noting challenges and opportunities:
- Performance Longevity: The tire maintained performance longer than expected, which some felt needed adjustment.
- Grip Versus Durability: Drivers experienced increased grip, but concerns about durability persist.
- Race Plan Influence: The tire’s characteristics shaped race plans, with drivers needing to adjust their approach.
Dale Earnhardt Jr., despite some reservations, acknowledged the tire’s potential to amplify racing excitement, emphasizing the need for tactical balance.
“When the cars are all on the primary, they don’t run side by side very much… they just start chattering and losing grip.” – Dale Earnhardt Jr.
Dale Earnhardt Jr.’s Analysis of the Option Tire
Dale Earnhardt Jr. provided a thoughtful analysis of NASCAR’s option tire, highlighting its remarkable impact on race dynamics. He emphasized the challenges associated with the primary tire, noting its tendency to cause cars to lose grip and limit side-by-side racing.
“I think you take that option tire and all the great things that it seems to be doing and keep going farther.” – Dale Earnhardt Jr.
Earnhardt Jr. explained that the option tire, in contrast, offered improved speed and durability, fostering more aggressive and competitive racing. He cited Joey Logano’s tactical use of the option tire as a proof of its effectiveness. After a penalty set Logano back, his team utilized the option tire to regain lost ground swiftly, ultimately leading him to the race’s forefront.
Despite the option tire’s benefits, Earnhardt Jr. sees potential for further progress. He urges NASCAR to continue improving the tire to amplify its impact on race competitiveness.
Other Drivers Who Benefitted from the Option Tire
Numerous drivers found themselves gaining a tactical edge with the option tire, showcasing its potential to alter race outcomes.
Ryan Preece showcased this at Phoenix, where he strategically pitted under a Lap 10 caution. Starting from the 29th position, he equipped his car with the red-lettered tires and impressively surged to finish Stage 1 in third place. This action highlighted the option tire’s ability to considerably improve performance.
Other notable beneficiaries included:
- Austin Cindric, who skillfully advanced from 14th to 8th in a single lap after a restart during the second stage.
- Erik Jones, who utilized the option tires to secure a top 10 finish, emphasizing its tactical advantage.
- Ty Dillon, whose adept use of the option tires allowed him to gain substantial ground in the final stage.
The Future of the Option Tire in NASCAR
The impressive performances by drivers using option tires at Phoenix have sparked conversations about their potential role in future NASCAR events. These tires have illustrated a tangible ability to alter the dynamics of the race, offering teams new opportunities for tactical maneuvers.
Their success suggests they could become a staple in the championship event later in the year, aligning with NASCAR’s vision of fostering more competitive and engaging races.
Justin Haley’s remarks highlight the groundbreaking impact of the option tires, as he expressed a desire to utilize them exclusively, feeling as though they endowed him with superhero capabilities.
“I wish I would have been on the option tires the whole time.”
“They just make you feel like superman.” – Justin Haley
This sentiment reflects a broader consensus among drivers who have experienced the advantages these tires offer. As NASCAR evaluates the option tire’s future, the focus will likely be on incorporating them in a manner that optimizes competitive fairness while enhancing the general spectacle for fans and participants similarly.
News in Brief: Dale Earnhardt Jr. on NASCAR’s Tire Gamble
The introduction of NASCAR’s option tire has sparked considerable changes in race dynamics, comparable to the impact of F1’s soft tires. Dale Earnhardt Jr. highlights its tactical benefits, enhancing competitiveness and providing drivers with new opportunities to excel.
As seen in the 2025 Phoenix Race, the option tire has allowed certain drivers to gain an edge. Looking ahead, the option tire holds promise for reshaping NASCAR’s future, potentially creating more thrilling and unpredictable races for fans and drivers similarly.
ALSO READ: Dale Earnhardt Jr. Questions NASCAR’s Call on Austin Cindric’s Penalty
