Key Highlights
- Introduction of the option tire has revitalized short track racing competition by encouraging varied team strategies.
- The option tire’s effectiveness is demonstrated by improved race dynamics and fluctuating positions based on tire usage.
- Expanded use of option tires at Phoenix Raceway showcased its impact, highlighted by Christopher Bell’s narrow victory.
- The 2024 NASCAR package changes, including a simplified rear diffuser and 3-inch spoiler, enhance the effectiveness of option tires.
- Denny Hamlin remains skeptical, advocating for better tire compounds and increased horsepower for genuine competition improvement.
The Decline of Short Track Racing in NASCAR
While short track racing was once synonymous with the intense, gritty spirit of NASCAR, recent developments have seen this traditional cornerstone of the sport falter, creating concern among fans and analysts likewise.
The introduction of the Next Gen car three years ago marked a turning point, as the balance shifted towards intermediate tracks thriving while short tracks began to struggle. Iconic venues like Bristol and Martinsville, once arenas of fierce competition and dramatic fender-banging moments, now confront challenges that undermine their historic allure.
The unexpected excessive tire wear during last year’s spring race at Bristol, following a rare return to concrete under the night sky, momentarily rekindled excitement, yet it remained an anomaly.
Subsequent races reverted to predictable tactical maneuvers, such as maintaining track position, as evidenced by Martin Truex Jr.’s commanding performance at Richmond. The unique circumstances at Bristol underlined that the solution to improving short track racing remains elusive.

The Introduction of the Option Tire and Its Impact
As NASCAR grapples with the challenges faced by short track racing, the introduction of the option tire emerges as a promising innovation aimed at revitalizing the sport. This new tire, initially tested at the All-Star race and Richmond’s spring event, illustrated its potential to improve competition, significantly capturing Dale Jr.’s attention.
“Hopefully, we continue to see that develop as we go further along the schedule and racing at these short tracks throughout the rest of the year [and] Goodyear continuing to push the tire and get more aggressive with the tire.” – Dale Jr.
By expanding its use beyond half-mile ovals to Phoenix Raceway, NASCAR effectively compelled teams to adopt varied strategies, improving the dynamics of the race.
View this post on Instagram
Christopher Bell’s narrow victory over Denny Hamlin at the Desert Mile highlighted the tire’s impact. However, it was Ryan Preece’s impressive climb from 33rd to 10th in just 11 laps, thanks to the softer, high-grip option tire, that truly displayed its influence.
Veteran journalist Jeff Gluck recognized the tire as revealing a key to racing with the Next Gen car, signifying a critical improvement for both short tracks and road courses similarly.
“this just now unlocked the true key to racing with the next-gen car because remember I mean it wasn’t that long ago where they’re like oh my gosh what are we gonna do we gotta try this different aero pack. We gotta try this the up-down splitter we’ve got a what are we gonna do we take off the underbody and downforce all stuff it’s the tires on the track this is unlocked so much whether for short tracks whether for road courses now this is the biggest track I tried it on a one-mile track it’s working it’s great.” – Jeff Gluck
How the 2024 NASCAR Package is Changing Racing
The 2024 NASCAR package represents a notable evolution in racing dynamics, highlighting NASCAR’s commitment to enhancing the competitive nature of its events. Implementing a simplified rear diffuser and a 3-inch spoiler, alongside a 670-horsepower engine, the package aims to challenge drivers by reducing downforce and increasing the need for skillful handling.
Dr. Eric Jacuzzi observed improved in-traffic performance, allowing cars to navigate with greater agility, especially on tracks like Phoenix, Richmond, and Martinsville.
“At the test, we noticed an improvement in traffic. The car didn’t lose rear downforce when it yawed… drivers could slide around more.” – Dr. Eric Jacuzzi
Ryan Blaney’s crash in Phoenix demonstrates the difficulty of maneuvering through dense traffic, even as the race saw 17 lead changes. Despite the package aiming to assist cars behind, leaders such as Bell still dominated by leading 103 laps, highlighting the ongoing challenge of overtaking, even as racing dynamics become more engaging.
“The goal was being better in traffic. Drivers always say they’re terrible in traffic.” – Ryan Blaney

The Option Tire’s Role in Racing Strategy
NASCAR’s 2024 package has already redefined the dynamics of racing, yet another intriguing element shaping race outcomes is the introduction of the option tire. This innovation compels teams to engage in tactical decision-making, balancing risk and reward.
As witnessed, the option tire creates a dynamic of ‘comers and goers,’ shifting race positions based on tire usage. However, the ultimate success still hinges on the team’s setup and driver skill, as exemplified by Bell’s victory.
Christopher Bell’s remarks encapsulate the tactical conundrum: does the option tire crown the best car, or simply the most opportunistic strategy? While Bell utilized both expert setup and driving insight, other top contenders like cars #11 and #5 highlighted the significance of tactical tire management.
“The option tire. Does it produce comers and goers? It does, but if you’re not good, then you’re gonna do the opposite, right? So what do we want the champion to be? Do we want the champion to be the best car, or do we want it to be the guy that sucked all race and saved a set of red tires that got the lucky yellow?” – Christopher Bell
Denny Hamlin’s Take on NASCAR’s Approach
Although the introduction of option tires has stirred excitement among racing enthusiasts, Denny Hamlin remains skeptical about their impact on the integrity of NASCAR competitions. Known for advocating improvements in on-track racing, Hamlin has persistently called for increased horsepower, a plea unmet by NASCAR.
Recently, his focus shifted toward urging Goodyear to develop a superior tire compound for short-track racing. Despite acknowledging the potential of option tires, Hamlin, a self-professed purist, is wary of their consequences on race fairness. He argues that the sport already offers numerous novelties, such as Lucky Dogs and Green-Light Checkers, questioning whether option tires might prevent the best car from winning due to degradation and tactical manipulation.
“I’m probably going to be too much of a purist for you guys. I just, we have so many novelties as it is, Lucky Dogs… Green-Light Checkers. We’ve done everything we can in the sport, rules-wise, to make it entertaining. I don’t know. I’m just too old school to tell you that I want options for tires. It’s just another way that the best car will not win.”
“Me and Dale Jr. believed for the longest time that Goodyear has the keys to NASCAR Cup Series racing, and I think it’s evident that we were right. We got tire falloff, we finally got them to put some soft tires on the car. The results from the racing we’ve seen speak for itself.” – denny hamlin
While he appreciates the tire falloff and soft compound, Hamlin proposes making option tires non-optional, envisioning a scenario where races are run solely on these tires, potentially transforming tactics on short tracks and one-mile ovals.

News in Brief: Drastic Step to Improve Short Track Competition
NASCAR’s introduction of the option tire has greatly influenced short track racing, offering teams a new tactical dimension that could revitalize the sport. By altering vehicle dynamics and enhancing competition, this innovation, part of the 2024 NASCAR package, has sparked discussions on its long-term implications. Denny Hamlin’s insights highlight the industry’s cautious optimism, as teams navigate these changes. Ultimately, this experiment emphasizes NASCAR’s commitment to evolving the racing experience while respecting the sport’s rich traditions.
ALSO READ: Goodyear Shuts Down NASCAR’s Tire Debate After Phoenix Shake-Up!