Katherine Legge entered the NASCAR Cup Series with high hopes, but her journey has taken a sharp and unexpected turn. Known for racing in IndyCar and sports cars, her time in stock cars has sparked strong opinions. Two race weekends brought more than just results—they brought trouble. One ended with a crash, the other with a bizarre issue inside the car. Now, questions are growing louder. Was this all a mistake, or is there more behind the scenes?
The Unprecedented Challenge of NASCAR Entry
Katherine Legge’s transition to NASCAR in 2025 has been anything but smooth. With a celebrated career spanning IndyCar, sports cars, and endurance racing, Legge brought a wealth of experience—but almost none of it in stock cars. Her NASCAR Cup Series debut, at Phoenix Raceway for Live Fast Motorsports, was marked by limited stock car experience: just four Xfinity starts and a single ARCA race, where she was collected in an early crash.
NASCAR granted her approval for road courses and tracks one mile and shorter, a standard classification for drivers with some oval experience but little stock car background. This immediately raised eyebrows among competitors and fans alike, many questioning whether she was truly prepared for the rigors of the NASCAR Cup Series.
On-Track Struggles and the Phoenix Incident
Legge’s first Cup race at Phoenix was a “baptism of fire,” as she later described it. She qualified last and, despite showing improved pace during the race, spun twice—the second time on Lap 215, leading to a crash with Daniel Suárez. The incident became a lightning rod for criticism. Suárez, while expressing support for women in racing, questioned NASCAR’s approval process, arguing that allowing a driver with such limited stock car experience into the NASCAR Cup Series was irresponsible. He suggested that if another driver had been in Legge’s position, they would have handled the situation differently, potentially avoiding the crash.
“There’s nothing wrong with her. What is wrong is NASCAR. They cannot allow somebody with no experience to run in the Cup Series. Plain and simple. Plain and simple. You go to Las Vegas, to a fast track, it’s freaking dangerous. You cannot do that. And then here, honestly, this is not a slow pace. Like, I hit her, and I was running 100 MPH, slowing down already.” – Daniel Suárez
Katherine Legge goes around and collects Daniel Suárez! 👀 #NASCARonFS1 https://t.co/z25cBIBQvE pic.twitter.com/VAYiUx99OL
— FOX: NASCAR (@NASCARONFOX) March 9, 2025
Dale Earnhardt Jr. weighed in on the controversy, but from a different angle. He argued that the real issue was not the approval process but the lack of sufficient practice time for drivers like Legge. On his podcast, Earnhardt Jr. highlighted how teams are not investing enough in practice, which he believes is a root cause of such incidents. The debate over Legge’s readiness and NASCAR’s policies became a hot topic in the sport, with many drivers and analysts taking sides.
The Mexico City Meltdown: Heat, Hurdles, and Headlines
Legge’s second NASCAR Cup Series start, at Mexico City’s Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez, was marked by an unusual and dramatic incident. Running in the top 20, she was forced to slow down when the extreme cockpit heat caused the sole of her racing shoe to melt and stick to the throttle pedal.
Radio transmissions revealed the severity of the problem, with Legge telling her crew her shoe was “literally fused to the pedal.” The team managed to free her foot, but she lost significant time and finished 32nd, five laps behind the winner. The incident became a viral story, sparking both sympathy and further debate about her place in the series.
While some praised her perseverance, others saw the episode as emblematic of her struggles to adapt to NASCAR’s unique demands. The incident also raised questions about whether the sport is doing enough to support drivers making the transition from other disciplines, particularly with the physical and technical challenges of stock car racing.
The Torrent of Abuse: Death Threats, Sexism, and Online Harassment
Perhaps the most disturbing aspect of Legge’s NASCAR journey has been the torrent of abuse she has faced off the track. Since her return to the sport, Legge has been inundated with thousands of hateful messages, death threats, vulgar comments, and sexual harassment. The abuse has been relentless, with critics questioning her right to compete and accusing her of being a “diversity hire” or a “gimmick” driver. Some have even urged her to take her own life or made violent threats against her.
Legge has spoken out about the abuse, describing it as “unacceptable” and “disturbing.” On her podcast, “Throttle Therapy with Katherine Legge,” she emphasized that she is in NASCAR to compete, not to be tokenized.
“I’ve worked just as hard as any of the other drivers out there… The teams that employed me—without me bringing any sponsorship money for the majority of those 20 years—did not do so as a DEI hire, or a gimmick… It’s because I can drive a race car.” – Katherine Legge
NASCAR has responded by providing Legge with additional security for her races and informing local law enforcement about the threats. The sport’s leadership has also publicly condemned the abuse, with NASCAR Commissioner Steve Phelps stating, “We denounce this behavior. It is unacceptable and inappropriate for NASCAR, sports, or society as a whole”. Despite the support, the abuse has highlighted the broader issue of gender-based discrimination in motorsports, a problem that extends beyond NASCAR and even the United States.
Media, Announcers, and the Public Discourse
The controversy surrounding Legge has also played out in the media and among NASCAR’s own broadcasters. Former NASCAR star Jamie McMurray was caught on a live mic during a CW broadcast, suggesting that Legge had “bought her way in” to her Xfinity Series ride. The comment sparked immediate backlash, with fellow announcers quickly moving to contextualize the situation, pointing out the challenges Legge faced as a last-minute substitute with little practice in an unfamiliar car.
While some in the media and the public have been supportive, others have used Legge’s struggles as an opportunity to question her legitimacy and the motives behind her participation. The debate has become a microcosm of the larger conversation about diversity, inclusion, and opportunity in racing, with Legge at the center of the storm.
News in Brief: Should Katherine Legge Be in a NASCAR Cup Car
Katherine Legge’s leap into the NASCAR Cup Series has ignited widespread debate. From on-track struggles in Phoenix to a bizarre shoe-melting incident in Mexico City, her adaptation to stock cars has been anything but smooth. Criticism from peers like Daniel Suárez, commentary from Dale Earnhardt Jr., and intense online harassment have made her journey even more challenging. NASCAR’s response to threats underscores the seriousness of her situation. While questions persist about her readiness, Legge remains determined to prove her worth behind the wheel.
ALSO READ: Katherine Legge Joins Natalie Decker in Elite Group of Women Leading NASCAR Races
