The ongoing fight between 23XI Racing, co-owned by Michael Jordan and Denny Hamlin, and NASCAR is changing the way teams do business in the sport. The case is about power, money, and who controls stock car racing’s future. For those unfamiliar with NASCAR’s system, the lawsuit is creating one of the biggest off-track stories in recent history, with a decision that could reshape how teams race and operate for years to come.
Key Highlights
NASCAR’s charter system gives teams guaranteed race spots and prize money shares.
23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports refused NASCAR’s new charter agreement in 2024.
Both teams filed an antitrust lawsuit claiming NASCAR acts like a monopoly.
A court removed their guaranteed spots; both now race as “open” teams weekly.
A major hearing is scheduled for late August 2025 to decide their future status.
What Is the NASCAR Charter System?
Introduced in 2016, the charter system works like a franchise license. Each charter guarantees a team a place in every Cup Series race and a fixed share of prize money. There are 36 charters in total, with four open spots available each week for non-chartered teams. Teams can sell or lease charters, creating value similar to traditional sports franchises. Without one, teams must qualify on speed every race and earn much less prize money.
This system gave teams financial stability, attracting sponsors and allowing long-term planning. A charter could be a team’s biggest asset, especially if they ever decided to leave the sport and sell their spot.
Why Did 23XI Racing Sue NASCAR?
In 2024, the agreement that defined how charters worked was set to expire. NASCAR introduced new terms for teams to sign, but 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports objected. They argued the deal hurt teams’ ability to make money and devalued charters.
Both teams filed an antitrust lawsuit, accusing NASCAR of running an illegal monopoly by controlling every aspect of the sport. The claim says NASCAR’s rules restrict competition, limit teams’ power, and force them into unfair deals.
NASCAR responded with its own lawsuit, arguing teams were working together to force changes for their benefit. The sanctioning body insists the system balances the sport’s needs, and that its rules are legal and necessary to keep the competition running smoothly.
What’s Really at Stake?
The core of the dispute is control and revenue sharing. Teams want a bigger say in how NASCAR is governed and a larger cut of the money from TV deals and sponsorships. They argue costs rise every season, while their share of the profits does not.
Teams also want their charters to hold long-term value. If NASCAR changes rules or limits sales, the ability to sell a charter like a sports franchise team could vanish. This uncertainty creates major risks for owners investing millions in the sport.
How Has the Court Ruled So Far?
Early in 2025, 23XI and Front Row asked the court to let them keep guaranteed spots while the lawsuit played out. A lower court agreed, but NASCAR appealed and won, removing that protection. Both teams now have to qualify on speed as “open” entries. They earn less money and face the risk of missing races if they don’t qualify.
While the court said NASCAR didn’t have to keep giving them charter spots, NASCAR has agreed for now not to sell their former charters to other teams. A bigger decision on their future is expected in a late August 2025 hearing.
The lawsuit also includes bold demands from the teams, such as asking NASCAR to sell its tracks or allow teams to race elsewhere independently. These are unlikely but show how far the dispute has stretched beyond a simple contract fight.
Why Fans Should Pay Attention
This legal battle could change NASCAR forever. If teams win, it could lead to a franchise-style model like the NFL or NBA, where owners hold more power and long-term security. If NASCAR wins, the current structure stays, giving the sanctioning body full control over race entries and how money is split.
Other teams are closely watching. Any ruling will set a precedent for future agreements, prize money negotiations, and how new investors view NASCAR as a business opportunity. Until the courts decide, off-track drama adds another layer to the 2025 Cup Series season.
News in Brief: 23XI Racing and NASCAR Lawsuit Explained
The lawsuit between 23XI Racing, Front Row Motorsports, and NASCAR stems from disagreements over the sport’s charter system and revenue-sharing model. Both teams refused new contract terms in 2024, claiming NASCAR runs an illegal monopoly that limits teams’ power and income. NASCAR countersued, arguing teams are trying to rewrite rules for their own gain. The court stripped 23XI and Front Row of guaranteed spots, forcing them to qualify each week. A critical hearing in August 2025 could redefine NASCAR’s structure.
ALSO READ: Denny Hamlin Builds 23XI Racing’s Culture as the Next Move Heads to Court
