The legal battle between 23XI Racing, Front Row Motorsports, and NASCAR is far from over. What began as a contract standoff in 2024 has now turned into something much bigger. With court orders still in place and key deadlines approaching, the situation continues to shift. A major hearing is just days away, and the final trial is already on the calendar. Behind it all is a timeline filled with bold moves, courtroom decisions, and unanswered questions about the future.
How the NASCAR Lawsuit Began
The dispute began on September 6, 2024, when 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports (FRM) refused to sign NASCAR’s new 2025 charter agreement, objecting to a clause that would force them to drop any legal claims against NASCAR. Both teams argued the deal was a “take-it-or-leave-it” offer that threatened their ability to compete and secure sponsors. In October 2024, they filed an antitrust lawsuit, claiming NASCAR’s charter system and business practices were monopolistic and unfair to teams. The legal battle quickly escalated, with both sides preparing for a lengthy court fight.
Key Legal Developments and Timeline
After the lawsuit was filed, the teams sought a preliminary injunction to keep their charters while the case proceeded. In November 2024, a judge initially denied this request but allowed 23XI and FRM to compete as open teams for 2025, meaning no guaranteed race spots or revenue. On December 18, 2024, a new judge granted a preliminary injunction, requiring NASCAR to allow both teams to sign charter agreements and approve their purchase of additional charters from Stewart-Haas Racing. NASCAR appealed, but the injunction stands for the 2025 season as the trial date was set for December 1, 2025.
Current Status and What’s Next
As of May 2025, 23XI and FRM are racing as three-car chartered teams under court order while NASCAR’s appeal is pending. The case is set for a jury trial in December 2025, and both sides are gathering evidence, including financial data from Formula 1 for comparison. NASCAR continues to argue the teams coordinated their actions, while 23XI and FRM maintain the lawsuit is about fairness and antitrust compliance. The outcome could reshape NASCAR’s charter system and team participation rules, making this one of the most significant legal battles in the sport’s history.
Detailed Timeline: 23XI Racing & Front Row Motorsports (FRM) Lawsuit Against NASCAR
Here’s a concise, up-to-date timeline of the ongoing legal battle between 23XI Racing, Front Row Motorsports, and NASCAR over the 2025 charter agreement:
September 6, 2024:
23XI and FRM refuse to sign NASCAR’s 2025 Charter Agreement, risking the loss of their combined five charters. This public holdout marks the start of the dispute.
October 2, 2024:
23XI and FRM file an antitrust lawsuit against NASCAR, alleging monopolistic practices and seeking court intervention to protect their ability to compete as chartered teams. They hire renowned antitrust attorney Jeffrey Kessler and announce plans to seek a preliminary injunction.
October 9, 2024:
The teams file for a preliminary injunction, requesting expedited discovery and making public several internal communications with NASCAR.
October 16, 2024:
NASCAR responds, stating the deadline to sign the 2025 Charter Agreement has passed and begins planning for a season with only 32 charters, threatening the teams’ guaranteed race participation.
November 4, 2024:
A preliminary injunction hearing is held; the judge aims to rule by November 8.
November 8–16, 2024:
The court denies the teams’ initial request for a preliminary injunction but allows them to race as open teams in 2025 while the lawsuit proceeds. 23XI and FRM file a notice of appeal and request an expedited appeal.
December 2, 2024:
NASCAR files a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing the teams’ complaints are not antitrust violations and that most alleged misconduct is outside the statute of limitations.
December 12–16, 2024:
New court filings reveal internal disputes over charter transfers and claims that NASCAR previously approved the transfers before requiring the teams to drop their lawsuit as a condition for approval. The teams respond to NASCAR’s motion to dismiss, standing firm on their antitrust claims.
December 18, 2024:
A judge grants a preliminary injunction requiring NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to sign the Charter Agreement and approve the transfer of additional charters from Stewart-Haas Racing. This ruling preserves their status as chartered teams for 2025 while the case continues.
December 23, 2024:
Judge clarifies that NASCAR must approve the transfer of Stewart-Haas Racing charters to both teams, allowing each to expand to three cars for 2025, but the teams must ask the court for specific approval.
March 5, 2025:
NASCAR files a counterclaim, accusing 23XI and FRM of orchestrating anticompetitive conduct and seeking to dissolve their charters and eliminate guaranteed starting spots for charter teams.
March 14, 2025:
23XI and FRM file their response to NASCAR’s appeal of the injunction. A hearing is scheduled for May 9, 2025, in the U.S. Court of Appeals. The trial is set for December 1, 2025.
Current Status (as of May 2025)
23XI and FRM are operating as three-car chartered teams for the 2025 season under court order, pending appeal. NASCAR is appealing the injunction and has filed a countersuit, seeking to revoke the teams’ charters and challenge their legal strategy. A major appeal hearing is set for May 9, 2025, with a trial scheduled for December 2025. The outcome could reshape NASCAR’s charter system and team participation rules.
News in Brief: May 2025 NASCAR Antitrust Case Update
The legal fight between 23XI Racing, Front Row Motorsports, and NASCAR began in September 2024 over the 2025 charter deal. After filing an antitrust lawsuit in October, both teams faced major legal hurdles but secured a court order in December allowing them to race as chartered teams in 2025. As of May 2025, the case is headed to a key appeals hearing on May 9, with a full trial set for December. The outcome could permanently reshape how NASCAR teams operate and compete.
ALSO READ: NASCAR’s Net-Zero Emissions Goal: Racing Toward a Sustainable Future by 2035
